Gas and electric furnaces are the two most common forms of home heating systems. Both have their advantages and disadvantages, so choosing which one is right for your home can be tricky. Differences in cost, efficiency, installation, and comfort between gas and electric furnace systems are explored in depth here to help you choose the best HVAC system for your home. We’ll also give you a rundown of the two main types of furnace systems and a comparison of their respective benefits and drawbacks. Everything you need to know to make the right decision for your home is included below.

On This Article hide

Cost Difference Between Gas and Electric Heaters

There are a few variables that can affect how much you spend on a heating system. The original cost of the furnace is only one part of the full cost of ownership, which also includes fuel and maintenance expenses.

An electric furnace system can be installed for far less money up front than a gas furnace system. The initial investment in an electric furnace system is typically lower than the initial investment in a natural gas system, but the ongoing expenditures, such as electricity, can be higher. Due to this, the long-term cost of an electric furnace system may exceed that of a gas furnace system.

Efficiency Comparison

When comparing gas and electric furnaces, the former is typically more efficient. Gas furnaces are more efficient than electric furnaces, which can waste some of the energy they consume. It is important to note, however, that the efficiency of a furnace system can also be affected by things like how well it was installed and how often it was maintained.

Two Most Common Furnace Installation Methods

Gas furnace systems are typically more complicated and may necessitate more time and skill for installation. This is because a gas line and venting system must be set up in conjunction with a gas furnace, which can increase the price and difficulty of the project. On the other hand, an electric furnace system needs an electrical circuit to be installed.

Comfort Levels Provided by Gas and Electric Furnaces

Both gas and electric furnaces can effectively heat a home to a comfortable temperature. However, gas furnace systems provide a more natural form of warmth, and electric furnaces are preferred by those who value uniform temperature control. Ultimately, the choice between gas and electric furnace systems will come down to personal preference.

Whether you go with a gas or electric furnace depends on a number of considerations, including how much you’re willing to spend, how much energy you need, and how much comfort you require. Take into account the local gasoline prices and availability. Finding the right furnace system for your home requires the expertise of a licensed HVAC technician.

Mechanical and Operational Differences

There are major technical and operational distinctions between gas and electric furnace systems. Depending on how they vary, these factors may affect the furnace’s efficiency and lifespan.

Systems that use gas for heating burn gas to produce heat, whereas those that use electricity to heat the air rely on electrical resistance to do the same. In other words, a gas furnace’s inner workings include the burner, the heat exchanger, and the flue that carries the fumes outside. By contrast, electric furnaces feature internal parts like heating elements and a blower motor.

To keep the burners and heat exchanger in a gas furnace in good working order, routine maintenance is required. A system might benefit from annual inspections and cleaning to keep it in good shape. While electric heating systems have fewer maintenance needs, they still need to have their filters cleaned and replaced on a regular basis.

Each type of furnace system has its own specific operational and maintenance needs, and knowing what those needs are will help you keep your furnace running smoothly and efficiently. 

Environmental Impacts

When thinking about how each type of furnace affects the environment, gas and electric systems require different measures. You should think about these before settling on a furnace system for your home.

Gas Furnace Emissions

Pollutants including carbon monoxide and nitrogen oxides are produced during the combustion process in gas furnace systems. Particularly in low-quality air regions, these contaminants can have an adverse effect on human health. Natural gas is the most common type of fuel used in gas furnaces, but its extraction and transportation can have harmful effects on the environment.

Electric Furnace Emissions 

While electricity generated from fossil fuels like coal or natural gas can be utilized to power an electric furnace system, the system itself does not cause any pollutants. This means that an electric furnace’s impact on the environment is very variable depending on the electricity source. Electric furnace systems have environmental impacts during both production and disposal.

The environmental effect of furnaces can be reduced with the use of emerging technology like high-efficiency gas furnace systems and renewable energy sources. In order to make the best eco-friendly decision for your home’s furnace, it is recommended that you speak with a competent HVAC contractor.

Safety Comparison

Safety is an important factor to think about when designing a heating system. There are specific dangers associated with using either a gas or electric furnace.

Gas Furnace Safety

An improperly installed or maintained gas line is a potential source of gas leaks in gas furnace systems. Also, gas furnaces produce heat through combustion, which can be dangerous if the system isn’t serviced regularly or if there are issues with venting. In order to guarantee the gas furnace is operating securely, it is essential to have it serviced and inspected regularly.

Electric Furnace Safety

Electric furnace systems may not provide the same concerns as gas furnace systems, but they nevertheless have their own set of potential hazards. Due to the electrical nature of electric furnace systems, improper installation or maintenance increases the likelihood of electrical shock or fire. Regular maintenance and inspections of an electric furnace system’s wiring and electrical components are necessary to ensure that the system is operating safely. It’s also crucial that the furnace system has been properly grounded and that the electrical circuit is of the right size and has been connected correctly to prevent overloads.

Keep in mind that both gas and electric furnaces benefit from routine inspections and maintenance to keep them operating safely. To reduce the likelihood of potential dangers, it is essential to work with a skilled HVAC contractor during the installation and maintenance of your furnace system.

Maintenance for Gas Furnace Systems

To keep the burners and heat exchanger in a gas furnace running smoothly and safely, routine maintenance is required. Cleaning and checking the system on a yearly basis might help keep it in top shape. Checking and cleaning the venting system is also crucial to ensuring that the furnace is functioning as intended and that no obstructions are preventing air from escaping. Carbon monoxide leaks, which can be harmful or even lethal, might occur if the system is not properly maintained.

Maintenance of Electric Furnaces

Regular cleaning and filter replacement are still necessary for electric furnace systems to function properly, although not as frequently as they would for gas furnace systems. In order to guarantee that the heating elements are in good shape and that the furnace is producing adequate heat, it is essential to have them inspected and cleaned regularly. The furnace’s ability to circulate air effectively depends on the condition of its blower motor, fan belt, and bearings, all of which should be inspected and serviced as needed.

If you want to make sure your furnace is operating safely and efficiently, you should talk to a professional HVAC contractor about the specific maintenance needs of your system and then set up regular maintenance and inspection appointments. Remember that regular maintenance may assist to ensure the safety and efficiency of your furnace system, as well as extend the life of your system and save you money by avoiding the need for repairs or replacements.

Price Comparison of Gas and Electric Heaters

When shopping for a heating system, it’s crucial to keep your budget in mind. It’s important to remember that the initial investment for either a gas or electric furnace system will vary in price.

One can expect to pay more for a gas furnace system’s installation than for an electric one. However, gas furnace systems, such as those that use natural gas, may have lower recurring costs than electric furnace systems, which use electricity. As an added bonus, gas furnaces often have a lower rate of breakdowns and repair needs than electric furnaces, which can translate to a lower total cost of ownership. The cost of a gas line installation, for example, is an additional expense that should be taken into account when budgeting for a gas furnace system.

When deciding on a heating system, it is vital to think about both the upfront and recurring costs. A more precise estimate of the costs associated with various furnace systems can be obtained through discussion with a skilled HVAC contractor. Additionally, it’s important evaluating the cost of fuel and availability in your location.

Conclusion

In conclusion, both gas and electric furnace systems have their own unique pros and cons. While electric heating systems may be less expensive up front and more low-maintenance in the long term due to recurring energy expenses, the former may not always be the case. Gas furnace systems tend to be more energy efficient and can produce a more natural warmth, but might be more expensive initially and require more regular maintenance.

It’s vital to think about things like price, efficiency, installation, comfort, environmental impact, and safety when selecting a furnace system for your home. You should also talk to an HVAC technician to make sure your furnace is setup and maintained properly. Think about these things so you can pick a furnace system that works for your house and your wallet.